Adam R. Bialek (Partner-New York) and Michael Barer (Associate-New York) weighed in on the Second Circuit's affirmation of a Southern District of New York finding that a digital music resale platform infringed on the copyrights of an American record label regarding the music files being resold. Adam and Michael suggest that the Second Circuit's decision "has reinforced a literal application of copyright as written rather than reconcile the intent of the first sale doctrine with modern technology." Clarification of this issue will require an action by Congress or the Supreme Court, they say. "In the interim, physical copies of such recordings will continue to be legally transferrable while digital versions will not."
The content of this article is intended to provide a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought about your specific circumstances.